The God of My Father
Lots of people have God experiences. Ones that make you go, "Holy crap. God IS real!"
Let's say it happens to a Catholic girl during a Church service. A boy at the beach, who comes from a Hindu family. A man in a mosque. An old Jewish lady at her home.
They all usually assume that the God they had an encounter with is the God of the religion they're most familiar with or have familial ties to.
How do we get past that? Meet God. And seek truth.